Pleasantly Surprised by Sense and Sensibility

I’ll admit it, I was skeptical. After all, I was practically raised on the brilliant 1995 Sense and Sensibility with Emma Thompson. How could this BBC miniseries match that? Did you SEE the actor they picked to play Willoughby? But I reluctantly agreed to watch it and ate every one of my cynical thoughts. I still love the 1995 film, but this miniseries had several things that portrayed the original story better.

The main actresses are great in their roles, showing Elinor’s emotion under her reserve and Marianne’s serious side under her emotions. They acted like real girls and sisters, and I had more sympathy for their decisions and thought processes. They also look the right ages according to the novel. While I still think they could have picked someone a little better looking for Willoughby to portray how he instantly charmed Marianne, I appreciate how it didn’t downplay Willoughby’s unpleasant side. You understand how flawed he is, especially through how it pays more attention to the girl he seduced and then abandoned. The movie version barely touches on that, making Willoughby out to be a charming, misunderstood lover of poetry who had no money, and not a notorious rake.

Then there is my favorite Jane Austen hero of all time, Colonel Brandon. I still love Alan Rickman, but David Morrisey’s portrayal of a gentle, retired soldier with a streak of righteous anger blew me away. I love how he doesn’t say much, but communicates his love for Marianne through a silent language of actions. Listening intently to her playing piano, bringing her sheet music, opening his home to her, and giving death glares to Willoughby is how he shows her he cherishes her.

Finally, the pacing of the miniseries is excellent. There are long periods of waiting in Marianne and Elinor’s love lives. The miniseries shows this through scenes of them staring out the window and taking walks along the beautiful seaside. In between the plot points, these quiet scenes give the viewer time to breathe and process, something a film has a hard time doing right.

I have many other things I love about it, (the score! the DUEL! the costumes!) but I hope the little I shared encourages you to try this miniseries yourself some quiet Sunday afternoon.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Hanna Judith is a Christian and small town librarian who loves babies, books, and the BBC.

6 thoughts on “Pleasantly Surprised by Sense and Sensibility

Add yours


    You did a wonderful job highlighting this adaptation’s strong points!! Yes, indeed, I love the slower, contemplative pacing and the feeling of waiting patiently. And David Morrissey’s Colonel Brandon is one of my favorite love interests, anywhere, ever. ❤

    that glare tho …

    Liked by 3 people

  2. This is one of my all-time favorite shows. I love practically everything about it. And I love how you point out some of my favorite elements: Hattie Morahan and Charity Wakefield as the Dashwood sisters, the quiet pacing, THE GLARE . . . such goodness. 😀


  3. I enjoy this version, mostly for Elinor and Edward. I feel it did them better justice than the Emma Thompson version, in which Hugh Grant seems stiff and awkward and miscast. But I admit, as good as this Marianne and Brandon are, they can never beat Kate Winslet and Alan Rickman in my heart.


    1. I have to agree with you. I love both of the Brandon/Marianne portrayals, but the 1995 has a little bit of the upper hand. (Probably because my mom watched it every couple months when I was a child so it’s #nostalgic.)

      Liked by 1 person

Interact With Us:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Website Powered by

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: